Early Warning: Tenuazonic Acid Contamination in Food Products

Tenuazonic acid, a mycotoxin produced by certain species of Alternaria fungi, has emerged as a persistent yet sporadic concern in food safety. Although the overall number of incidents has remained low over the past decade, their appearance has raised alarms among food safety authorities due to the potential health risks associated with this toxin. Tenuazonic acid's presence in the food supply, even in limited quantities, poses a threat to public health, making it a substance that requires constant monitoring. This article examines the early warning signs detected across the European market, the specific incidents that have been recorded, and the measures needed to mitigate future risks.

What is Tenuazonic Acid and Its Dangers

Tenuazonic acid is a naturally occurring mycotoxin linked to a variety of food products, particularly grains, spices, and certain vegetables. This toxin is known for its neurotoxic and hematotoxic effects, causing concern among toxicologists and food safety experts. What makes tenuazonic acid particularly dangerous is its ability to withstand common food processing methods. This resistance makes it a persistent contaminant that can affect a broad range of food products if not properly monitored.

The compound’s chemical structure enables it to interfere with protein synthesis, potentially leading to cell damage and immune system suppression. While studies are still ongoing, the possible carcinogenic effects of tenuazonic acid have placed it under greater scrutiny. This toxic potential has prompted food safety authorities to prioritize the detection and control of tenuazonic acid within the food supply chain, even in low-concentration scenarios.

Recent Incidents: A Close Look at the Data

Tenuazonic acid contamination has raised significant concerns over recent years, highlighted by a few key incidents that have caught the attention of food safety authorities. These incidents, although not widespread, underscore the ongoing threat of this toxin to the global food supply and reinforce the need for vigilance.

This insight has been timely identified and is available to users through the SGS Digicomply Food Safety Intelligence Hub. Feel free to explore the Food Safety Intelligence Hub demo and try this tool in action.

One of the most recent and notable cases occurred in September 2024, when tenuazonic acid was detected in paprika powder sourced from Spain and distributed via the Netherlands, with Germany being the notifying country. The European Commission validated the notification, which triggered follow-up actions. Although no immediate health crisis was reported, the case highlighted vulnerabilities in the supply chain, particularly in the import and handling of spices. This incident serves as a stark reminder that contamination risks are present even in well-monitored food categories like paprika, often used widely across the European market.

Earlier in May 2024, there was a concerning report involving high levels of tenuazonic acid in paprika spice, detected by Swiss food safety authorities. This case was particularly significant because it involved a popular spice widely used in Europe, raising questions about the conditions under which the contamination occurred and emphasizing the importance of closely monitoring spices and condiments, which can often harbor mycotoxins due to their drying and storage processes.

An additional incident dating back to April 2023 involved dried figs from Türkiye that contained tenuazonic acid among other mycotoxins. Germany, again at the forefront of the notification, reported the contamination. This incident pointed to the risks associated with importing dried fruits from regions where storage and handling conditions might favor the growth of Alternaria fungi, the primary producer of tenuazonic acid.

These recent cases are not just isolated events; they represent a pattern that demands a more proactive stance from regulatory bodies. The incidents primarily involve imported products, underlining the complexities of managing a globalized food supply chain, where contamination risks can originate from diverse regions and pass through multiple hands before reaching consumers

Geographical Impact: A European Perspective

The majority of tenuazonic acid incidents have been reported in Europe, with countries such as Germany, Switzerland, and other EU members at the forefront of detection. This geographical focus is not due to a higher risk of contamination but rather a reflection of Europe’s stringent monitoring standards. European countries, with their advanced food safety frameworks, have been able to identify these sporadic cases more effectively, providing a model for other regions.

The prominence of Germany in the incident reports is a direct result of its comprehensive food safety infrastructure, which includes regular inspections and advanced detection techniques. Switzerland’s role in reporting tenuazonic acid incidents in tomato-based products highlights the importance of tracking food imports and the challenges of controlling contamination in cross-border trade.

Product Categories Most at Risk

The detection of tenuazonic acid has been linked to a variety of food products, suggesting that no single category is immune. However, certain food groups appear to be more susceptible based on recent incidents:

• Spices and Condiments: Paprika, in particular, has surfaced repeatedly in recent notifications, indicating a vulnerability to contamination during drying and processing stages. The spices' extensive use in European cuisines increases the importance of monitoring these products.
• Dried Fruits: Items such as dried figs from Türkiye have shown traces of tenuazonic acid, highlighting the risks associated with storage and import conditions that favor fungal growth.
• Tomato-Based Products: Incidents involving strained tomatoes and related products point to the challenges of maintaining quality in processed foods, where contamination can go unnoticed until routine checks are conducted.

These product-specific vulnerabilities emphasize the need for targeted monitoring and industry awareness about potential contamination risks during production and storage.

Health Risks: The Impact on Consumers

The health implications of tenuazonic acid are significant, even at low exposure levels. The neurotoxic properties of this mycotoxin can lead to dizziness, confusion, and neurological disturbances, particularly among vulnerable populations like children and the elderly. Additionally, tenuazonic acid’s ability to induce hematotoxic effects, including hemorrhaging and internal bleeding, necessitates a cautious approach to managing contamination.

Long-term exposure, although not fully studied, raises concerns about carcinogenic potential, which has driven calls for stricter regulatory standards. This makes tenuazonic acid a priority target for food safety agencies that aim to minimize exposure through rigorous controls and public awareness campaigns.

Regulatory Response: Actions Taken by Authorities

European food safety bodies have responded to the tenuazonic acid threat with increased vigilance. The use of rapid alert systems, such as the RASFF, has played a crucial role in identifying contaminated products before they reach consumers. The current approach focuses on:

• Routine Testing: Implementing scheduled sampling across various food categories to detect mycotoxins early.
• Traceability Systems: Enhancing traceability from farm to table, ensuring that contaminated batches can be quickly identified and removed from the supply chain.
• Public Communication: Keeping the public informed about potential risks, even if incidents remain isolated, to maintain consumer trust.

These efforts, while effective in managing risks, require constant updates to adapt to evolving agricultural practices and environmental conditions that could influence mycotoxin levels.

Future Trends: Addressing Challenges in Monitoring and Prevention

Looking forward, the challenge of tenuazonic acid contamination will hinge on advancements in detection technologies and a more integrated global approach to food safety. The implementation of advanced analytical methods, such as Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (LC-MS), offers promise for detecting lower concentrations of tenuazonic acid, allowing authorities to act faster and with more precision.

In addition, international cooperation among food safety agencies will be essential for addressing the cross-border nature of mycotoxin contamination, ensuring that standards are aligned and that data is shared transparently. This collaborative approach will be crucial for minimizing risks and ensuring that early warnings are heeded effectively.